-
"But if you’re a traditional newspaper editor — who thinks in terms of X number of articles for X pages in X upcoming papers — the content cascade model probably sounds as doable as standing at the mouth of a river and trying to catch two A1 stories in a paper cup."
-
"Hussman said during the webinar, titled "From Free to Fee," that the Democrat-Gazette's pay wall helps it remain the primary source of information for the state."
-
"The river of news is the direction things are headed in. It’s clear people are getting more comfortable with that."
-
"The business side seems to think they’re getting something far more magic than mere microformats can provide. The bloggers, meanwhile, have clearly been too hasty in their vaporware accusations."
-
"But does focusing on journalists as news companies’ most valuable asset mean that news companies should be exclusively in the content production business? That’s a significant shift from the industrial printing and distribution business."
-
The first Guardian embedding of a BBC video. I don't quite know what to make of this personally.
-
"Half-hour programmes will be preceded by short commercials, while programmes of one hour or longer will be interrupted by a commercial break."
-
"Shares in business-to-business publishing and information group Reed Elsevier plunged by 14% today after the Anglo-Dutch company said today it would sell new shares to cut its debt pile."
-
A report compiled purely through Twitter.
-
"Great journalists with their hearts in the community are being shrugged off and those who are left are totally disillusioned by the whole disintegration process."
-
"slideViewer is a lightweight (1.5Kb) jQuery plugin wich allows to instantly create an image gallery by writing just few lines of HTML such as an unordered list of images."
-
"…we’re putting together a list of new revenue opportunities that will go up on the site in the next few days."
-
MarkMail is a free service for searching mailing list archives, with huge advantages over traditional search engines.
-
"Trinity Mirror said that it had shut 22 titles since the start of the year and cut 900 jobs – bringing headcount reduction to 1,800 in the last 18 months."
-
"The company behind the “spyware” distributed to BlackBerry users in the United Arab Emirates as part of an apparent government surveillance effort exposed last week is neither a shady hacking outfit nor a false front for a team of spies in a bunker.
Instead, SS8 is based in Silicon Valley…"
Author Archives: Joanna
A BrandNew project for me
For those who may have concluded my lack of blogging meant I’d disappeared off the planet, I thought I’d draw your attention to just one of the things I’ve been beavering away at behind the scenes.
BrandNew was set up in response to the fact that brand management online seemed to be a bit of a dirty word. While some organisatons are awarded the digerati prize of having “got it“, others end up being marginalised and scorned for their obvious errors.
Yet, I don’t think it should be such a maligned profession. As long as you are open, honest and transparent about who you are; who you work for; what you’re doing and why and sensitive to other people then being in a space where customers can easily access you should be a great thing. Right?
But being someone who has (without realising it at first) helped to manage the identity of a brand online, I am all too aware of the soul-searching that this type of role can create.
Questions such as: Can I be myself? What should I write about? Can people distinguish between my organisation’s brand and my personal identity? How do I deal with putting myself in the front line of customer service? How will my bosses react to what I say online? What if I get it wrong?
Looking back to the wonderful, supportive atmosphere of the Birmingham Social Media Cafe, I hoped that I could recreate that atmosphere for those faced with such questions.
Hence, the BrandNew meetups. The first one isn’t until September 10 so there is plenty of time to let me know how I can make it better, and to tell your friends! Any feedback would be much appeciated.
Oh, and there’s a Facebook Group too!
BBC video embedding – proof of commodity news?
I’ve had little time to mull over the implications of the announcement that the BBC is to share its video content with Daily Mail & General Trust, Guardian News & Media, Telegraph Media Group and Independent News & Media. Yet, in the moments when I have, I have this nagging worry that it is not a good sign.
I can completely see the benefits: additional video content that can really enrich a story, but at no real cost to the newspaper groups involved. Plus, if you’re getting BBC content on your favourite newspaper website, perhaps you might switch your homepage allegiance.
The one thing that has personally been bugging me is that the owners of the Daily Mail, The Guardian, The Telegraph and The Independent all decided that BBC content would sit well alongside their stories.
This suggests that they thought it likely that they would be covering enough of the same stories as the BBC, and doing so with a tone and style that was unlikely to clash.
So a BBC video would sit as well next to a Daily Mail article as it would a Guardian article? When the unique selling points of a newspaper are supposedly its focus, editorial tone and world view, that seems surprising.
I guess you could argue that it is a testament to the BBC’s objectivity and that each newspaper group will have different priorities: selecting video for different stories.
But I can’t get yesterday’s quote from Vivian Schiller, CEO of NPR in the US, that “news is a commodity” out of my head.
I’ve got this horrible feeling that the BBC deal proves that many articles produced by newspapers provide little or no uniqueness to help distinguish them in a flooded market.
links for 2009-07-29
-
As newspapers weaken and die, most people probably become less informed about local affairs, but a few motivated folk grow extremely knowledgeable. Ms Price will miss the Bedworth Echo, but not as a source of news. It was, she says, a useful way of getting the word out.
-
A Chicago lettings agency is suing a former tenant for at least $50,000 (£30,000) after she complained on Twitter about mould in her apartment.
-
Perhaps RoboCop “writers” building information aggregators will be all that’s left in media’s post-apocalyptic future.
-
"Just as Ham Radio, Desktop Publishing and Blogging all promised the rise of the Amateur, only to see it replaced over time by the Pro-Am and then the Pro, we suspect this too will disappoint."
-
Fascinating interview with Malone. A must for anyone interested in the financial situation of the media industry (if you can put up with ads).
"The Internet side of it is going to have to have some consolidator. It doesn't mean you own everything, it just means somebody is going to be the intermediary to authenticate, provide security and provide collection… I think cable is probably in as good a position as anybody to be the consoildator of that functionality." -
Photographers react to an amateur's photo being bought by Time for $30 and used on the magazine's front cover.
-
"Frankly, if all the news organizations locked pinkies, and said we're all going to put up a big fat pay wall, you know what, more traffic for us. News is a commodity; I'm sorry to say."
-
As of now the site pulls in about 8,000 unique visitors a month and enough paid subscribers to keep it in the black
-
"It's really simple. You stick in your location, and we tell you stuff that's near it."
-
"…the EU is prepared to "suspend trade benefits granted to the U.S." if its domestic Copyright Act is not updated to fit World Trade Organisation rules."
-
"The copying and reproduction of just 11 words of a news article can be copyright infringement, the European Court of Justice (ECJ) has ruled."
-
"Ortiz is showing that people are interested in serious news on the Web, especially if it A) impacts their lives, B) is timely and C) provides a great community."
-
"Microsoft’s news and entertainment portal MSN wants to add UK regional newspaper content to its MSN Local site, integrating papers’ feeds with with its postcode-searchable map."
-
"Just as brands conduct audits of inventory, employees, and budgets on an often annual basis, they should also survey the landscape to find out what customers, influencers, partners and employees are participating on the social web."
-
"It will give pre-pay customers unlimited access to tracks from Universal Music's extensive catalogue and let them play them on any mobile phone."
-
"We have consistently argued that content dumping by a publicly-funded broadcaster distorts the market and undermines the investment in video by commercial providers, such as the Press Association," said a PA spokeswoman.
-
"Teens trying to hash out (sub)cultural identities today have message boards, fan sites, and YouTube diaries to turn to, not to mention Facebook groups and musicians' MySpace pages. And that's perhaps the greatest crisis facing music magazines: They're being phased out, to a significant degree, by social-networking media, too."
-
"As time goes by, a bacterial computer will actually increase in power as the bacteria reproduce."
links for 2009-07-28
-
"What’s Social Journalism? It’s what you do when you gather information in social media channels and then report it to your readers."
-
"The 90s and 00s have been full of companies churning out the same old lame, toxic junk and trying to sell it in new ways — instead of detoxifying it."
-
"Newspapers strive for circulation, by telling the same stories in the same ways — in slightly different places. Nichepapers strive for scarcity: to develop a perspective, analytical skills, and storytelling capabilities that are inimitable by rivals."
-
"Journalists at Trinity Mirror's Birmingham-based newspapers have called off strike action after the company agreed to make no compulsory redundancies at the titles."
-
"It’s time to take news to the next level, to a form that not only informs and educates, but also has strong replay value."
-
The NYTimes.com has opened up a self-serve ad system for businesses who want to advertise on its hyperlocal sites.
-
Both had resolutions that might not have made traditional media, but were important to the users and, for me, resulted in the sort of engagement you want from media
-
"My view is that winners in the Internet era of news journalism will be the people and companies who, like Cheezburger, ReadWriteWeb and Amazon, develop systematic ways of filtering the flood of user-generated content and sources down to those with the best content."
-
"It's too quiet. We're losing readers. Someone write a wrongheaded article about Twitter."
-
"sites, services and software that could be used for hacking without programming knowledge as a pre-requisite"
-
"National newspapers have a total of 1,068,898 followers across their 120 official Twitter accounts – with the Guardian, Times and FT the only three papers in the top 10."
-
""None of the traditional media conglomerates are also significant video game players, so to speak, and I think that that's the missing piece of the equation, particularly when you see how much time is spent playing games online," Miller said."
-
"Well guess what, if you're a not for profit, you still have to raise all the money that you're spending and then some, so you have a surplus when the economy goes off a cliff."
-
"Any media outlet serious about online conversations needs to show to commenters that they are serious – by engaging with them in a debate. Otherwise, commenting sections on news sites become a graveyard for the blurbs of self-obsessed people."
-
I've turned BIS's Twitter strategy into a generic template Twitter strategy for government Departments.
links for 2009-07-27
-
Firstly, Google will rank a page more highly if it includes more outgoing links.
Secondly, people will return to your site more often if they know they can expect useful links.
So get your act together, please.
Alan Rusbridger: “Blurring the distinction between journalist and reader”
Alan Rusbridger on the Future of Journalism from Carta on Vimeo.
I have just come across this video of Alan Rusbridger talking about the development of journalism.
I think it’s interesting to hear an editor admit that there is more knowledge and expertise outside his organisation amongst his readers than within it.
I’m now waiting for mainstream news brands to take the next step and talk about their journalists being in the service of their readers. It’s not something that gets mentioned too often but I think is an important mindset to start developing.
NB. Also David Montgomery of Mecom has also been uttering some wise words along the same lines.
QIT#9 Reader empowerment beyond content
This one really brings the incoherency of the QIT series to a new level. So please, bear with me:
I’ve been hearing a lot of debate about how news organisations need to re-engage with their readers and, for the most part, this seems to focus on content creation.
There is talk about promoting “citizen journalism”, using “UGC”, releasing APIs for developers, etc. etc.
It’s all good stuff. But there is no denying that those who volunteer time and effort to create news-worthy content or applications are a tiny minority.
Most people just want to be told what the news is by people who are employed to know.
Does that mean those who create want to engage more than those who do not? I don’t think that’s necessarily true.
Perhaps it’s just that others have time and skill barriers that stop them. Or they don’t really see how such engagement would benefit them.
I’m always stunned by how popular polls on news websites are. They almost always do well, perhaps because of their low barrier to entry: just one or two clicks and you’ve contributed.
The frustrating thing is that most of these polls are – beyond capturing a mood – utterly futile.
Readers may overwhelmingly vote that the Prime Minister should resign, but that poll is unlikely to have much influence on Gordon’s decision to bow out.
To look at it in the more negative light, you could argue such polls do little more than reinforce the idea that news organisations pay lip service to engagement, but don’t really want to empower their readers in any meaningful way.
So, what if polls were devised to empower? What if, at the end of the vote, the majority will of the readers was enacted? What message would that send out? What should the questions be?
The Birmingham Mail’s Gareth Barry letter: why so late on the web?
Did anyone else notice that today’s fantastic exclusive from the Birmingham Mail – an open letter from Gareth Barry to Villa fans – did not appear on its website until after lunch?
It seems many other websites ended up covering the story publishing the letter online before the Mail did.
Some even ran the full letter on their websites before The Mail. The Express & Star had the letter up online at midday and Football 365 appears to have published it at 12.31pm. However, Head of Multimedia for Trinity Mirror Regionals, David Higgerson (see comments below) said many of these were actually excerpts.
The Mail had originally had an article and a teaser on their site saying that they would publish the full letter online at 4pm, although it appeared to go up onto the site a bit earlier than that.
It’s a very different strategy to the way The Guardian broke its recent video exclusive on Ian Tomlinson, where it used its website to publicise the story first. I’m also not sure how it could have benefited the Mail to publish on their website so late.
I guess it shows the way newspapers deal with exclusives and how best to split them between print and online is still an area very much open to debate.
Is this useful? An account of how I started blogging and how it changed my journalism
I’ve just been going through my Google Docs and came across this draft post I wrote back in March last year about how I got into blogging.
I didn’t publish it at the time, thinking some of the things I was saying about The Birmingham Post wouldn’t go down too well considering the upheaval the newspaper was going through.
As you can see, it isn’t finished – and I certainly had no idea that in a year I’d be working for The Times – but I thought I’d post up what was there because it is a record of how I got into blogging and might be of some use to someone.
Let me know if it is and whether you think I should try and bring it up to date!
You know what you should do?” said Stef to me on the night of The Media Guardian Awards as we sat mulling over the night’s award-winning, stage-invading, surreality:
“Write a post explaining how things have changed since you started your blog.”
It’s one of those suggestions that makes your heart sink to your boots. Yes, I agreed, it would be a good exercise. But then so much has changed since September 2007 that I’m not sure I’m able to put it all into words.
But, having had a break for Easter, I feel re-enthused enough to give it a go:
The easiest way to sum it up is this: In August 2007, I was fed up with the state of UK newspapers and seriously considering my employment options. In March 2008, I am still fed up with the state of UK newspapers but now firmly committed to the industry.
So, what has changed?
I have always loved the internet and have been an active member of forums and chat rooms since I was a teenager. But, in all that time, I never considered that I deserved a corner of the web to call my own. I contributed to other people’s websites, but that was as far as I thought I would ever get.
I think that attitude came from the same stable as my dislike for writing newspaper opinion pieces. I’m happiest when I’m learning from and with others: bouncing ideas around.
A column doesn’t do this. It takes a stance, argues its case, ends the conversation. I think there is a confidence bordering on arrogance that you must have to write columns. I just didn’t have it.
My lack of confidence also extended to being unsure I had anything of value to say at all, because I didn’t think I held any strong opinions.
Then, some time in the spring of 2007, along came Birmingham blogger Pete Ashton. Really, Pete had been there all along, building Birmingham’s blogging community but I hadn’t really paid attention until I was directed to his Created in Birmingham blog by a member of AWM after following up a story for The Birmingham Post’s Media & Marketing page.
At first I ignored it as a rather amateurish publication. But soon I was intrigued.
At the time I saw it as a different model for distributing certain types of news and information. What stood out for me at the time (and I hope Marc, my editor, will forgive me for saying this) was as far as “What’s On”-style coverage of the specific creative sector in Birmingham was concerned, CiB kicked The Birmingham Post’s butt. It would take me much longer to understand how important it was in serving its community and giving it a voice.
So I followed CiB for a few months, found out what I could about its author and sent an email asking to have a chat. Pete, catching the whiff of mainstream journalism, promptly ignored me.
It took until Birmingham’s Creative City Awards in September for me to convince Pete to meet me. I had badgered Marc to take a table at the event and, as a result, I got to choose which guests to invite. Pete was the wildcard – I didn’t think he’d accept. But I was delighted when he did.
Luckily, we got on. Actually, as time has passed I think we’ve realised we’re doing similar things, just coming at them from completely different angles.
It was Pete – who many Birmingham blog scene know as an ardent recruiter of bloggers – who told me to write a blog. He had to tell me twice, because at first I said I wasn’t interested.
Although, I didn’t really know what I was doing with the thing, with hindsight I can see from the second post on I started exploring the idea of increasing audience interaction.
I swore Pete to secrecy and asked him not to tell anyone what I was doing.
I also kept it from The Birmingham Post. Not because I had plans to use it as a bitching platform, but because I was genuinely nervous about revealing more of my personality publicly. I thought I’d be a rubbish blogger.
But I didn’t understand that by linking to other people’s blogs, they would know of my existence anyway. So it wasn’t long before I got a few comments…and people were friendly.
The third post was another voyage of discovery. I outpoured about Birmingham and its support of the creative sector. As well as comments, this time Pete broke his silence and blogged about what I had said. Then things started to roll: suddenly people I didn’t know were getting in touch saying that they had read my blog. Then the Head of Communications at Birmingham City Council called to arrange a meeting to discuss my post.
The last one was particularly strange and got me thinking about the power of blogging. I could have written exactly the same thing in The Birmingham Post, which has tens of thousands more readers than my blog, but would I have got that response from the council? I am pretty sure I would not.
It was when I announced a change to my reporting role, that Marc found out about the blog. I’ll be honest, he didn’t find out from me (I hadn’t dared to tell him), but from a colleague of mine who had mentioned it to him.
I remember being told Marc knew and waiting nervously to find out what he was going to do about it. He didn’t do anything. In fact, I believe he walked past my desk and said: “like the blog”. I don’t think to this day he knows how relieved I was to hear that!
But still, the blog had an audience, and suddenly I didn’t really know what I was supposed to write about. Coming from journalism training that teaches you that there is a form and structure to the way you write, a empty blog page was a bit of a nightmare. There was no convention to cling to. It was entirely up to me what I wrote.
It was the post Blogisfear where I expressed that and, with the help of those that commented, particularly Nick Booth, I began to realise that it was only journalists who thought they always had to finish the stories by themselves. On blogs there was collaboration, often a story would remain open-ended. I started to think about why that wasn’t being applied in the same way to news.
I became engrossed in the concept of “Web 2.0” – that there were millions of people out there thinking, creating content and collaborating. I had no more ownership over content or news than they did and, in fact, it was my responsibility, as supposedly employed to be “the eyes and ears of the people” to consult them about what I was doing.
I decided to start asking people to put forward questions for people I was interviewing. This had varying degrees of success and was something I enjoyed (it’s died out a bit now as I don’t interview people all that often now).
Pete told me this was known as “crowd-sourcing” and had a wide range of potential applications for newspapers. I can not stress enough how helpful it was to have someone that I could call to have coffee with and pick their brains on how the web “worked”. I started to look at journalism in a new way through Pete’s explanations of blogging.
It was also Pete, I think, who was the first person to teach me the concept of blogging as a conversation.
I first joined the UK journalism “conversation” the day I wrote about Roy Greenslade leaving the NUJ. His decision was a fantastic catalyst for me to write about what I had been discovering for myself about the future of journalism. Some of the things I write about make me smile now (they were nearly there, but not quite), but I had some great feedback from people in the industry.
One commentor was Craig McGinty, who introduced me to the idea of papers developing online communty. It’s funny. Looking back at Craig’s comment, I remember at the time thinking that it was unlikely that any newspaper would employs a person with “the responsibility to help local groups and organisations set up blog-driven sites.” Now, after launching 35 bloggers on The Birmingham Post website, that idea seems perfectly reasonable!
The NUJ debate also showed me how blogging can take you into the heart of a community as, within a few posts, I was debating in the comments section of my blog with Donnacha Delong – the journalist that had sparked the whole debate in the first place with an article in The Journalist.
By the time Trinity Mirror’s chief executive Sly Bailey turned up at our offices, to explain why The Birmingham Post & Mail was no longer for sale, I was being watched by a number of management-types in the company… which was a little unnerving to say the least.
So much so, that I actually stopped posting for a bit, worried that I was starting to act like a monkey performing tricks to try and impress an audience.
It’s something that has continued to be on my mind when I write. I still want this to be a home for half-baked ideas and chats with colleagues, but you can not forget that what you say can make people pretty darn cross… as I was to discover a bit later into my blogging experiment.